Why Didn't R2-D2 Recognize Yoda?
By
Staten Island, NY Posted: 11/7/2016 1:00:00 AM
Do you remember the scene in The Empire Strikes Back where Luke and R2-D2 first see Yoda? If you've seen the Prequels, you would expect R2-D2 to recognize him, but he doesn't.
The Star Wars Prequels were great films, but there are a few continuity issues, especially concerning the Droids. In a previous post, I mentioned the fact that Ben Kenobi should've recognized R2-D2 and C-3PO in the Original 1977 Star Wars. That particular video generated a lot of debate, but this one is a lot more cut and dry.
Since R2-D2's memory was not erased at the end of Episode III, there is absolutely no reason why R2-D2 wouldn't recognize Yoda when they look for him on Dagobah. When you look at the scene now, it's pretty strange considering R2 definitely should recognize him. It's not like there are a millions little green men with that distinct voice in the universe.
Of course, George Lucas could've had an easy out if he simply had R2's memory erased at the end of Episode III, like he did with C-3PO, but he had a very good reason for making sure R2's memory was NEVER erased. According to Lucas, the Droids are an essential part of the Saga itself, and R2 in particular is vital, because Lucas's intention was that the story itself was being told through a narrator who was there for the whole thing, and that Narrator is none other than R2-D2.
WIth R2-D2 as the Narrator, it's critical that he not only survives every story, but that his memories of the events are never wiped out. Of course, this also means that as the Narrator, R2 has a tendency to see himself as a hero, which isn't all that far fetched. R2 saves the day at least once or twice per Episode.
Why Doesn't Ben Kenobi and Darth Vader Recognize R2-D2 and C-3PO? Idea of the day #60
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knhBDGphXRo
Joe Crescenzi, Founder
(Reply N/A) (Edit Topic N/A)
(Like Topic N/A) [0 ] 5811 Views
Related Posts
Fun(39)Movies(44)Star Wars(34)
Top 25 Posts
* Note: The ideas on "Idea of the Day" were posted without any formal research into existing inventions.
In some cases, patents may already exist for these ideas, in other cases, there may not be any existing patents and you are free to develop and explore the viability of developing and patenting the ideas.
The authors make no claim that any of the ideas are safe, practical, or suitable for any particular purpose. You are responsible for the results of trying, developing, patenting or using any of the ideas on this site.
For some people, our ideas are just an interesting read, but our goal is to encourage you to take action. If you see an idea that you like, do something with it... Take action.
- Joe
Idea of the Day!
on...