Why Are There No Sportscaster Interventions?
By
Staten Island, NY Posted: 2/16/2015 1:00:00 AM
We get it. Umpires and referees are the final word. But what if they are clearly wrong?
When Instant Replay came along, Sportscasters and TV viewers suddenly had the power to not only get a second look at a controversial play, but see it played out in slow motion... from 6 different angles.
As technology improved, and the quality of the replays has improved, some sports now have rules that allow a team to request a video review. The trouble with the system is they created a ton of complicated rules that often result in a play not being reviewed.
Among other things, the coach has to request the review before the next snap, which sounds pretty simple, but if he does this every time he thinks there's a chance a bad call was made, he risks losing time on the clock if he's wrong, which happens 2 out of three times. Most of the time, the coach makes the decision to challenge the call without even seeing the replay, so they often decide not to challenge the play.
The bottom line is that the coaches have very little time to make the decision, and once the decision is made, the referee has only 60 seconds to review the play.
Since Sportscasters and TV crews have first access to replay footage, they are clearly the first ones to know when they spot a bad call.
It seems to me that when they spot a clearly bad call, instead of just talking about how bad the call was, they should have a way to at least call for an official review if the coaches don't do it first.
It's not important that they eliminate the old rules, but simply add the ability for the networks to step in when there is clear evidence that a bad call was made.
Some may argue that technology undermines the integrity of the game by taking the human element away from umpires and referees. I don't think that's the case. It just gives them a better view. They still make the final call. It just gives them a better view.
Joe Crescenzi, Founder
Related Media:
(Reply N/A) (Edit Topic N/A)
(Like Topic N/A) [0 ] 6580 Views
Related Posts
Sports(15)
Top 25 Posts
* Note: The ideas on "Idea of the Day" were posted without any formal research into existing inventions.
In some cases, patents may already exist for these ideas, in other cases, there may not be any existing patents and you are free to develop and explore the viability of developing and patenting the ideas.
The authors make no claim that any of the ideas are safe, practical, or suitable for any particular purpose. You are responsible for the results of trying, developing, patenting or using any of the ideas on this site.
For some people, our ideas are just an interesting read, but our goal is to encourage you to take action. If you see an idea that you like, do something with it... Take action.
- Joe
Idea of the Day!
on...